India Hate Lab: ‘Alarming Increase in Hate Speech in BJP-Dominated Areas’!

Alarming Increase in Hate Speech in BJP-Dominated Areas!

Revealing Troubling Patterns: When Political Discourse Takes a Dangerous Turn

MOHAN KHOUND

In a concerning revelation, a detailed study conducted by the India Hate Lab, a Washington DC-based organization monitoring hate speech against religious minorities in India, has uncovered a significant surge in hate speech incidents targeting Muslims in the year 2023.

A total of 668 incidents were recorded, with a troubling 75% of these occurring in regions governed by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), including Delhi, where law and order falls under the jurisdiction of the Union government.

The report titled ‘Hate Speech Events in India‘ paints a grim picture, particularly highlighting that 36% of these incidents involved explicit calls for violence against Muslims, while 25% included speeches targeting Muslim places of worship.

The latter half of 2023 witnessed a staggering 62% increase in such events, rising from 255 in the first half to 413. This surge coincides with election periods in states like Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Telangana, and Chhattisgarh, hinting at a possible correlation between political campaigning and the rise of hate speech.

RelatedPosts

Boeing’s Safety Under Scrutiny: Are Its Aircraft Still Reliable After Repeated Incidents?

June 13, 2025

Crash of Air India Flight AI171 Ignites Global Concerns Over Aviation Safety

June 13, 2025

তথ্য-শোষণ ! আমাৰ তথ্য–আমাৰ অধিকাৰ

June 13, 2025

Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, and Madhya Pradesh emerged as the states with the highest number of hate speech incidents. The report underscores the stark contrast in the nature of hate speech between BJP-ruled and non-BJP-ruled states, revealing a higher prevalence of incendiary speeches in the former. A concerning 78% of incidents involving direct calls to violence and targeted attacks on places of worship were documented in BJP-administered regions.

Interestingly, while the involvement of BJP leaders in hate speech was more frequent in non-BJP-ruled states, in BJP territories, only 10.6% of events included their leaders, compared to 27.6% in opposition-ruled states.

This suggests a strategic use of hate speech by the BJP to gain traction in regions outside their control. Furthermore, prominent right-wing organizations such as the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), Bajrang Dal, and other affiliates of the Sangh Parivar were implicated in almost half of all reported hate speech incidents.

The report also highlights a trend where organizations dedicated to cow protection, like the Gau Raksha Dal, regularly engage in hate speech. Alarmingly, a few speakers, including key BJP figures and Hindu religious leaders, were responsible for a significant portion of these hate speech incidents.

In an international context, the report notes the exploitation of the Israel-Gaza conflict to fuel anti-Muslim sentiments in India. A substantial number of events during the last quarter of 2023 utilized the conflict to portray Indian Muslims as a threat to Hindus.

“The report titled ‘Hate Speech Events in India’ paints a grim picture, particularly highlighting that 36% of these incidents involved explicit calls for violence against Muslims, while 25% included speeches targeting Muslim places of worship. The latter half of 2023 witnessed a staggering 62% increase in such events, rising from 255 in the first half to 413. This surge coincides with election periods in states like Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Telangana, and Chhattisgarh, hinting at a possible correlation between political campaigning and the rise of hate speech.”

Case studies presented in the report illustrate the symbiotic relationship between hate speech and subsequent violence, with notable incidents in Nuh, Haryana, and Kolhapur, Maharashtra. These examples underscore the tangible consequences of unchecked hate speech and its potential to disrupt social cohesion.

The report concludes by highlighting the emergence of new “entrepreneurs of hate” who, alongside established hate groups, are pushing the boundaries of minority-targeted aggression. This escalation of extreme positions is creating new avenues for hate speech to flourish and is challenging societal norms.

In addition to this analysis, the debate surrounding blasphemy and hate speech in India reveals a complex legal landscape. Section 295(A) of the Indian Penal Code, which deals with acts intended to outrage religious sentiments, has been at the center of this discussion.

While the Supreme Court upheld its legality in the 1957 Ramji Lal Modi case, the interpretation of this law has evolved over time. Current standards require a direct link between speech and imminent unlawful action for prosecution.

Despite these legal nuances, there is a growing demand to differentiate between blasphemy and hate speech. Critics argue that the broad wording of Section 295(A) is often misused, conflating religious criticism with incitement to hatred. Data from the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) indicates a significant rise in hate speech cases, signaling a concerning trend that challenges democratic principles and free speech.

The report from India Hate Lab not only highlights the alarming escalation of hate speech in India but also sparks a crucial conversation on the need for clearer legal definitions and enforcement that distinguish between blasphemy and genuine hate speech, safeguarding both religious sentiments and the foundational values of free expression.

The expansive investigation by the India Hate Lab, based in Washington DC, has sounded the alarm on a sharp rise in hate speech incidents within India, particularly those targeting the Muslim community.

The study, recorded in their report “Hate Speech Events in India,” brings to light that out of 668 documented cases of hate speech in 2023, a disproportionate 75% occurred in regions under the governance of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). The nation’s capital, Delhi, where the Union government has jurisdiction over law and order, is also implicated.

Diving deeper into the content of these hate speech incidents, the study reveals a disturbing reality where 36% involved direct incitements to violence against Muslims, and 25% specifically targeted Muslim places of worship. This trend saw a significant spike in the latter half of the year, jumping by 62% from the first six months, with a total of 413 incidents reported.

This increase in hate speech is notably concurrent with state election campaigns in Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Telangana, and Chhattisgarh, suggesting a concerning link between political activities and the amplification of such rhetoric.

States like Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, and Madhya Pradesh stood out for their high incidence of hate speech. The report also sheds light on the different characteristics of hate speech across regions, noting a higher frequency and intensity in BJP-ruled states. Specifically, 78% of the incidents that included calls to violence and attacks on religious sites were reported in these areas.

The involvement of BJP leaders in these hate speech incidents varies geographically. While their participation was more frequent in non-BJP-ruled states, in BJP-dominated areas, a smaller 10.6% of events featured BJP leaders, as opposed to 27.6% in states ruled by the opposition. This pattern suggests that the BJP may be using hate speech tactically to consolidate influence in regions beyond their control.

Moreover, the report implicates right-wing groups such as the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), Bajrang Dal, and other Sangh Parivar affiliates in almost half of the hate speech incidents. It also notes the role of cow protection groups like the Gau Raksha Dal in disseminating hate speech. A handful of influential figures, including BJP politicians and Hindu religious leaders, have been identified as key sources of this harmful discourse.

Internationally, the report observes how the Israel-Gaza conflict was exploited to stoke anti-Muslim sentiments in India. This misuse of an international issue illustrates the broader strategies employed to deepen religious divides within the country.

The report presents case studies from places like Nuh in Haryana and Kolhapur in Maharashtra that exhibit a direct connection between hate speech and resulting acts of violence, emphasizing the real-world impact of such rhetoric on communal harmony and public safety.

The emergence of “entrepreneurs of hate” is also noted, indicating a worrying trend where new actors join established hate groups to amplify minority-targeted aggression. This is reshaping societal norms and creating environments where hate speech can thrive unchecked.

Regarding legal matters, the debate over blasphemy and hate speech in India is complex. Section 295(A) of the Indian Penal Code, which addresses actions meant to insult religious beliefs, comes under scrutiny. Despite the Supreme Court upholding its constitutionality in the 1957 Ramji Lal Modi case, its interpretation has evolved to require a direct correlation between speech and immediate illegal activity for legal action.

Critics call for clearer differentiation between blasphemy and hate speech, citing the misuse of Section 295(A)‘s broad terms, which often conflate religious critique with incitement to hatred. The National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) data underscores a rise in hate speech cases, a trend that poses a challenge to democratic values and freedom of speech.

The findings of the India Hate Lab report not only spotlight the troubling escalation of hate speech in India but also ignite an essential debate on the need for precise legal definitions and enforcement. Such measures would ensure a balance between protecting religious sentiments and upholding the fundamental principles of free expression.

Images from different sources

Mahabahu.com is an Online Magazine with collection of premium Assamese and English articles and posts with cultural base and modern thinking.  You can send your articles to editor@mahabahu.com / editor@mahabahoo.com (For Assamese article, Unicode font is necessary)