• Terms of Use
  • Article Submission
  • Premium Content
  • Editorial Board
Saturday, May 21, 2022
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Cart / ₹0

No products in the cart.

Subscribe
Mahabahu.com
  • Home
  • News & Opinions
  • Literature
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Gallery
  • Mahabahu Books
    • Read Online
    • Free Downloads
  • E-Store
  • Home
  • News & Opinions
  • Literature
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Gallery
  • Mahabahu Books
    • Read Online
    • Free Downloads
  • E-Store
No Result
View All Result
Mahabahu.com
Home News Special Report

THE GOODS AND SERVICES TAX: A CONSTITUTIONAL ANALYSIS

-Devapreeti Sharma

by Admin
June 17, 2021
in Special Report
Reading Time: 6 mins read
0
tax documents on the table

Photo by Nataliya Vaitkevich on Pexels.com

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

-Devapreeti Sharma |

The one-year old Goods and Services Tax (GST) has been called “the key to the future”.[1] But if one were to subject it to a legal treatment, one would reckon that GST is jurisprudentially flawed. This is because GST violates the principles of ‘cooperative federalism’, which is our “cherished constitutional goal.”[2] Conceding to the sanctity of this institution and the need to observe brevity in this essay, it would be wise to begin with the suspicion that cooperative federalism is not, as the term might otherwise suggest, simply about the tiers of the government cooperating with one another (which is, parenthetically, an ethical requirement in all forms of governance). It is a federal structure which solidifies unitary ideas whilst also countenancing the states to operate independently within some limited contours. It thus, “involves the sharing of authority between federal and state agencies, often leaving state agencies with discretion to implement broad federal policy goals…”[3] The true spirit of cooperative federalism can be gauged from Cyr’s parameters – (i) Autonomy (ii) Subsidiarity and (iii) Solidarity[4] – subsequently examined in the context of the Indian GST.

RelatedPosts

Mexico’s 100,000 ‘disappeared’ is a tragedy

Mexico’s 100,000 ‘disappeared’ is a tragedy

May 18, 2022
close up shot of an ocean

প্ৰশান্ত মহাসাগৰত ১০ কোটি বছৰ শুই থকা তেওঁলোক এতিয়া জাগি উঠিছে

May 18, 2022
Human rights must be at heart of solution to Sri Lanka crisis

Human rights must be at heart of solution to Sri Lanka crisis

May 18, 2022

The autonomy of a political unit is determined by the extent of control over its laws. It exists when one government is free from the controls of a higher tier of government. Thus, in a model of cooperative federalism, the states must be fairly autonomous in their spheres i.e. the states must be empowered to legislate on the subjects assigned to them. This is the ‘positive function’ of autonomy. Autonomy also performs a negative function – it excludes the centre from intruding into the states’ sphere of legislative competence and vice versa.[5] The Constitution of India, before the 101st Amendment was passed, provided for a complete dichotomy in taxation-powers of the centre and states, thereby performing both the positive and negative function of autonomy. Tax-based entries found a place only in List I (Union List) and List II (State List) of the Seventh Schedule.[6] Therefore, traditionally, taxes levied by a state cannot be levied by the centre and vice versa. However, with the insertion of Article 246-A, the centre and states are concurrently authorised to levy GST. States have now lost the freedom to choose their tax-rates. A choice to change the tax-rate would mean approaching the GST Council, thereby surrendering to the sanction of a special majority of weighted votes.[7] Consequently, the states’ freedom of economic and developmental pursuits has also been curtailed to a great extent. This is a grave sacrifice at the altar of autonomy.

The second parameter – subsidiarity – has to be understood in terms of ‘proximity’ and ‘effectiveness’.[8] Proximity indicates nearness to the subject of legislation, implying that local matters must be dealt with locally. Effectiveness means the ability of a government to do what it is meant to. The principle of subsidiarity denotes that a state must deal with its matters, but, if not effectively done, the centre must intervene. Thus, subsidiarity endorses pluralism and provides the states’ the means to meet their ends whilst also offering the centre’s assistance as a last resort. The Indian constitution is replete with provisions intended to make this principle manifest.[9] However, the implementation of GST has distorted this principle. While “efficient taxation” is a stated reason for the introduction of GST[10], no statement has been made on what was inefficient in the earlier scheme of state taxation. This, coupled with the fact that GST is believed to be fundamentally flawed in several aspects,[11] indicates utter disregard to the ‘proximity’ element in the principle of subsidiarity. It appears that the centre is intervening in areas quite uncalled for.

With regards to solidarity, one must mean political solidarity, which comes from a sense of belonging to a common body politic. It is a political value which refers “to the concept of membership in a moral community or the collective, intersubjective bonds that hold autonomous moral agents together.”[12] ‘Autonomous moral agents’ would require complementary self-regulating actors who would think of themselves as being comprised in a common body politic. Therefore, the principle of solidarity, in the context of cooperative federalism, would effectively involve self-governing states playing the role of ‘autonomous moral agents’ and identifying themselves as members of the common political project. Solidarity, then, is not to be equated with ‘unity’ or ‘uniformity’, which is what the Prime Minister categorically wishes to achieve with GST,[13] and quite successfully so – the dual character of GST empowers the centre and states to levy the tax on the same tax-base. Subsuming as many as thirty-four state taxes[14], GST prescribes the same tax-rate for the centre and all the states, payable through the same procedures. It thus appropriates the taxation capacity of the states, thereby making them passive actors of the play. By compelling states to yield their powers of taxation in favour of the centre, GST not only violates the doctrine of full faith and credit[15] which operates on, inter alia, the legislative enactments over which the states have jurisdiction[16], but also, belittles the states’ roles in the common body politic. The goal of “one nation, one tax” thus undermines the solidarity principle.

Herein rests the case against GST. GST, which has been hailed as “a classic example of cooperative federalism”[17] (for mere reasons like allowing the tiers of the government to share a common platform i.e. the GST Council, prescribing similar and simpler procedures of tax-payment for these tiers, launching a common national market etcetera) does not, paradoxically, stand positive on any of the parameters used for qualifying a federal model as one of cooperative federalism. Closing on a political note, perhaps it is time we relooked at the Prime Minister’s usage of his “key to the future”.[18]

[1] B. Chandrashekhar, Cooperative federalism key to progress, says Narendra Modi, THE HINDU (Aug. 8, 2016, 06:02 IST) http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/Cooperative-federalism-key-to-progress-says-Narendra-Modi/article14557879.ece.

[2] Swaraj Abhiyan v.Union of India, A.I.R. 2017 S.C. 3516 (India).

[3] Philip J. Weiser, Cooperative Federalism and Its Challenges, 2003 MICT. ST. DCL. L. REV. 727, 729 (2003).

[4] Hugo Cyr, Autonomy, Subsidiarity, Solidarity: Foundations of Cooperative Federalism, 23 CONST. F. 20. (2014).

[5] Id, at 22.

[6] See INDIA CONST. art. 246 (giving exclusive autonomy to the states and the centre to legislate on subjects assigned to them through the Lists of Seventh Schedule).

[7] INDIA CONST. art. 279-A, cl. 9 (implying that constituting a majority in the GST Council would require the centre and at least 20 states).

[8] CYR, supra note 4, at 26.

[9]See e.g., INDIA CONST, art. 249 (expanding the centre’s powers in national interest) and art. 353 (expanding the centre’s powers during Proclamation of Emergency) and art. 356 cl.1 (expanding the centre’s powers during state emergency).

[10] Vishal Raheja, What is GST?, TAXMANN (Jul. 12, 2017) https://www.taxmann.com/blogpost/2000000048/what-is-gst-goods-and-services-tax-explained-with-benefits.aspx.

[11] Jadhav Bhika and T.A. Rajput, Challenges and problems of GST in India, 4 IJMRD. 5, 8 (2017). See also Bharat Goenka, A fundamental flaw in GST, THE BUSINESS LINE (Aug. 2, 2016) http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/a-fundamental-flaw-in-gst/article8933956.ece.

[12] MAX PENSKY, THE ENDS OF SOLIDARITY: DISCOURSE THEORY IN ETHICS AND POLITICS 1-20 (1 ed. 2008).

[13] ANI, PM Modi credits team India, says GST is ‘great step towards transformation, THE BUSINESS STANDARD (Aug. 8, 2017) http://www.business-standard.com/article/news-ani/pm-modi-credits-team-india-says-gst-is-great-step-towards-transformation-116080801499_1.html.

[14] Government of India, GST Concept and Status, GOODS AND SERVICES TAX COUNCIL (Sept.1, 2017) http://www.gstcouncil.gov.in/gst-concept-status-01092017.

[15] INDIA CONST. art. 261, cl.1, 2 (collectively called the ‘doctrine of full faith and credit).

[16] Gauri Lal Gurdev Das v. Jugal Kishore Sharma, A.I.R. 1959 P.H. 265 (India).

[17] S.N.V. Sudhir, GST example for cooperative federalism: Nirmala Sitaraman, THE TIMES OF INDIA (Jul. 8, 2017, 16:47 IST) https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/india-business/gst-example-for-cooperative-federalism-nirmala-sitaraman/articleshow/59503260.cms.

[18] CHANDRASHEKHAR, supra note 1.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • Print
  • Email

Like this:

Like Loading...
Tags: GSTService Tax
Admin

Admin

Related Posts

Mexico’s 100,000 ‘disappeared’ is a tragedy
World

Mexico’s 100,000 ‘disappeared’ is a tragedy

by Admin
May 18, 2022
0

Mexico’s 100,000 disappeared!! UN The news that more than 100,000 people in Mexico are now officially registered as “disappeared” is...

Read more
close up shot of an ocean

প্ৰশান্ত মহাসাগৰত ১০ কোটি বছৰ শুই থকা তেওঁলোক এতিয়া জাগি উঠিছে

May 18, 2022
Human rights must be at heart of solution to Sri Lanka crisis

Human rights must be at heart of solution to Sri Lanka crisis

May 18, 2022
ধৰ্মীয় অসহিষ্ণুতা

ধৰ্মীয় অসহিষ্ণুতা

May 18, 2022
NEIPF : Interest of the indigenous people of NE must be protected

জনগোষ্ঠীয় সমন্বয়

May 15, 2022
photo of elephants on grass

ANALYSING THE MYSTERIOUS DEATHS OF 18 ELEPHANTS AT KANDOLI HILLS

May 12, 2022
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Emergence Of The KNF In Chittagong Hill Tracts

Emergence Of The KNF In Chittagong Hill Tracts

May 12, 2022
নাগালেণ্ডত পুনৰ ভাৰতীয় সৈন্যৰ নৃশংস হত্যালীলা !!

নাগালেণ্ডত পুনৰ ভাৰতীয় সৈন্যৰ নৃশংস হত্যালীলা !!

December 5, 2021
নাগালেণ্ডত পুনৰ ভাৰতীয় সৈন্যৰ নৃশংস হত্যালীলা !!

Indian Army’s Civilian Killings in Nagaland Again!

December 5, 2021
বিদায় অনিমেষ, বিদায় !

বিদায় অনিমেষ, বিদায় !

November 30, 2021
girls with signs on protest against russian war on ukraine

UKRAINE DIARY: Today is the 3rd day of war

1

The Chainsmokers Actually Make a Great Nickelback Cover Band

0

Obama Wants To Visit Ubud On Low-key Bali Vacation: Bali Official

0
man in black shirt standing on top of mountain drinking coffee

মোৰ হিমালয় ভ্ৰমণৰ অভিজ্ঞতা

0
 Assamese women nominated in Crain’s New York Business Awards

 Assamese women nominated in Crain’s New York Business Awards

May 21, 2022
ৰিচাৰ্ড ফাইনমেনৰ দৃষ্টিত বিজ্ঞানৰ স্বৰূপ

ৰিচাৰ্ড ফাইনমেনৰ দৃষ্টিত বিজ্ঞানৰ স্বৰূপ

May 21, 2022
কিংবদন্তি বড়তালা আৰু ইতিহাসে কথা কয়

কিংবদন্তি বড়তালা আৰু ইতিহাসে কথা কয়

May 21, 2022
Why should Afghan girls suffer?

Why should Afghan girls suffer?

May 21, 2022

Popular Stories

  •  Assamese women nominated in Crain’s New York Business Awards

     Assamese women nominated in Crain’s New York Business Awards

    32 shares
    Share 13 Tweet 8
  • Emergence Of The KNF In Chittagong Hill Tracts

    306 shares
    Share 122 Tweet 77
  • RISHIRAJ ADHIKARY, AN ASSAMESE SCHOLAR BAGS FULLBRIGHT-NEHRU FELLOWSHIP  

    16 shares
    Share 6 Tweet 4
  • The Heaven on Earth: KASHMIR

    18 shares
    Share 7 Tweet 5
  • সংগীত : এক চিকিৎসা পদ্ধতি

    9 shares
    Share 4 Tweet 2
  • AFGHAN WOMEN: ‘My life was never easy as everyone’s life’

    7 shares
    Share 3 Tweet 2
  • Women under Islamic Emirate of Taliban

    7 shares
    Share 3 Tweet 2
  • An Interview of Indrani Baruah by Jahnavi Gogoi

    34 shares
    Share 14 Tweet 9
  • ভাৰতত ‘চিঙ্গল ইউজ’ প্লাস্টিক নিষিদ্ধ হ’বঃ ১ জুলাইৰ পৰা 

    6 shares
    Share 2 Tweet 2
  • NEIPF’s ‘Diphupar Declaration’

    80 shares
    Share 32 Tweet 20
Mahabahu.com

Mahabahu is a collection of premium articles, opinions and writes from the writers all around the world.

Category

Site Links

  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact

We are Social

Facebook Twitter Youtube LinkedIn
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact

© 2021 Mahabhahu.com - All Rights Reserved. Published by Powershift | Maintained by Webx

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News & Opinions
    • Politics
    • World
    • Business
    • National
    • Science
    • Tech
  • Entertainment
    • Theater
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Dance
  • Lifestyle
    • Fashion
    • Travel
    • Health
    • Food
  • Gallery
  • Mahabahu Books
    • Read Online
    • Free Downloads
  • E-Store

© 2021 Mahabhahu.com - All Rights Reserved. Published by Powershift | Maintained by Webx

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Oops!! The Content is Copy Protected.

Please ask permission from the Author.

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
%d bloggers like this: