5th report on the Media in Ukraine
UKRAINE: 5th report on the State of Media in Ukraine during the War (April 12-22) – The besieged and destroyed Ukrainian Mariupol in the spotlight
Lviv (Ukraine), 22 April 2022.
Key Ukrainian topics in the media: Russian warship and Mariupol
The first big news story for both Ukrainian and world media was the death of the
flagship of the Russian fleet in the Black Sea “Moskva” (literally “Moscow”),
allegedly from Ukrainian missiles. Until now, neither the exact number of dead
Russian sailors, nor the exact circumstances of the sinking of the warship are
known. But the fact of the destruction of the craft is recognized by both sides of the
war.
The second dramatic line concerns the besieged Ukrainian city of Mariupol in the
south of the country. Russian troops control almost the entire territory of the city,
except for the industrial zone of the Azovstal metallurgical plant. According to the
mayor of the city, Vadym Boychenko, there are still over 1,000 civilians and several
hundred Ukrainian soldiers in the basements of the plant.
Both stories, as well as the lack of information about what is happening in the
Russian-occupied territories in southern Ukraine, raise the difficult issue of access to
truthful information during the war. Journalists often have to blindly rely on the words
of their sources, since it is impossible to verify information under conditions of war or
occupation. This makes journalists and their audiences vulnerable to propaganda.
Investigative journalists are the best at this challenge, thanks to their skills in
analyzing social networks, satellite images, documents, databases, and previously
verified sources.
The death toll of media persons in the war is on the rise
Already 21 journalists and media persons were killed (local and international both),
dozens wounded.
The list of killed journalists in the line of duty:
1. Yevhen Sakun, cameraman of LIVE TV channel (died on March 1 during the
Russian rocket attack on the TV tower in Kyiv);
2. Brent Renaud, a former correspondent for The New York Times (shot dead by
Russians on March 13 in Irpen at a checkpoint);
3. Pierre Zakrzewski, cameraman for Fox News, an Irish citizen (killed on March
14 during an artillery shelling by Russian troops in the village of Gorenka, Kyiv
region).
4. Oleksandra Kuvshynova, Ukrainian producer, journalist (killed on March 14
together with Pierre Zakrzewski during an artillery shelling by Russian troops
in the village of Gorenka, Kyiv region).
5. Oksana Baulina, a journalist for Russia’s The Insider and Oleksiy Navalny’s
Anti-Corruption Foundation (killed on March 23 during an Russian shelling in
Kyiv while performing an editorial assignment).
6. Dilerbek Shakirov, a civilian journalist of the information weekly “Around You”
(was shot dead by Russians at a blockpost in the suburbs of Kherson on
February 26)
7. Viktor Diedov, cameraman of Sigma TV from Mariupol (died on March 11 as a
result of shelling of his house)
8. Maks Levin, famous Ukrainian photojournalist, has not been heard from since
13 March, when he was reporting in the Vyshgorod district, north of Kyiv. On
April 2 he was found dead in the Kyiv region in places of massacre of
civilians.
9. Eugene Bal, 78 yo journalism veteran, died near Mariupol on April 2. He was
kidnapped and tortured by the Russian military for three days in late March.
After his release, his health deteriorated and he died.
10.Olexander Lytkin, journalist dtp.kiev.ua. The circumstances of his death are
unknown. His name among the dead was published by the office of the
Prosecutor General of Ukraine without details.
11. Roman Nezhyborets, video technician was killed in the Ukrainian village of
Yahidne. His body was found by Ukrainian volunteers on 6 April after Russian
troops withdrew from the area. Nezhyborets’ body had gunshot wounds in the
knees and his hands were tied.
12.Zoreslav Zamoysky, local residents in Bucha found his body on a street in the
city in early April, according to statements by the Ukrainian National Union of
Journalists (NUJU) and the Irpin city council. Those sources did not state the
exact date his body was found.
Journalists who were killed not in the line of duty (as soldiers or volunteers).
13. Victor Dudar, who was a military journalist and served as a part of the Armed
forces, was killed in battle on March 6, near Mykolaiv.
14.Oleg Yakunin, the editor of the Zaporizhia site Misto.zp.ua, was killed in battle
on March 25 on military service.
15. Yuriy Oliynyk, the operator of the 24th channel was killed in battle on March
23 in the Luhansk oblast, near Popasna. Yuriy was a volunteer in the 24
separate mechanized brigade named after King Danylo.
16.Pasha Lee, Ukrainian actor and TV host, has been killed by shelling in the city
of Irpin.
17.Serhyi Pushenko, graphic artist and painter who worked with media, killed by
Russian sabotage and reconnaissance groups in Kyiv region on 2 March.
18.Sergey Zaikovsky, publicist and translator who worked with media, killed in
Kyiv region on 24 March.
19.Denis Kotenko, one of press-officers of the Ministry of Veterans Affairs, killed
in Kyiv region on 24 March.
Killed media persons (people who are connected with the media, but were not
directly journalists):
20.Mantas Kvedaravičius, Lithuanian documentary filmmaker and director of the
Mariupol film about the war in Donbass, died on April 3 in Mariupol.
21.Lilia Gumyanova, a journalism teacher was killed by Russian shelling in
Mariupol on March 19.
Freedom of speech in Ukraine
In our last reports, we wrote how Ukrainian authorities have tightened control
over the media in Ukraine during a war time.
Unfortunately, the situation remains the same. Three national news channels with
varying ties to former Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko have been taken off the
digital air. They continue to broadcast on satellite, cable networks and online, but
have lost, according to various estimates, from 20 to 40 percent of their audience.
(Disclosure: the report’s author also works for a TV channel that has been taken offline from digital broadcasting)
Other national news channels (both private and public) work together and create the
United News. These news are broadcast on the frequencies of at least six TV
channels and at least one radio station, as well as on the public services digital
platform Diia.
Thus, the Ukrainian authorities may be trying to reduce the intensity of criticism after
possible truce agreements with Russia. At the same time, Ukrainian President
Volodymyr Zelensky limits the media influence of his political rival, former President
Poroshenko.
Another problem is the crisis of local media in Ukraine. Because of the war, many
local newsrooms from the east and south of the country were forced to leave for
safer western regions. Some of the journalists went to defend their homeland in the
army, the other part changed their profession or temporarily stopped working and
solves everyday problems associated with relocation.
According to Eugene Zaslavsky, executive director of the Media Development
Foundation, a non-governmental organization, today local media need not only
material support and help with relocation. Such editorial offices are losing contact
with the communities that they wrote about earlier, they are losing access to sources
and their qualified personnel. And new employees of such editorial offices often need
intensive training.
It is especially difficult for publications from the territories occupied by Russia to
work. But even after the liberation of such territories, the material and technical base
of such media is destroyed, and their work is complicated for various reasons. For
example, because of the mined lands in previously peaceful cities.
23-04-2022
# Andrii Ianitsky is journalist now based in Lviv and PEC Representative in Ukraine
His first report was published on 19 March 2022, the second on 28 March 2022, the third on 5 April 2022, fourth on 11 April
Mahabahu.com is an Online Magazine with collection of premium Assamese and English articles and posts with cultural base and modern thinking.