• Terms of Use
  • Article Submission
  • Premium Content
  • Editorial Board
Sunday, June 15, 2025
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Cart / ₹0

No products in the cart.

Subscribe
Mahabahu.com
  • Home
  • News & Opinions
  • Literature
  • Mahabahu Magazine
    • December 2023 – Vol-I
    • December 2023 – Vol-II
    • November 2023 – Vol-I
    • November 2023 – Vol-II
    • October 2023 – Vol-I
    • October 2023 – Vol-II
    • September 2023 – Vol-I
    • September 2023 – Vol-II
  • Lifestyle
  • Gallery
  • Mahabahu Books
    • Read Online
    • Free Downloads
  • E-Store
  • Home
  • News & Opinions
  • Literature
  • Mahabahu Magazine
    • December 2023 – Vol-I
    • December 2023 – Vol-II
    • November 2023 – Vol-I
    • November 2023 – Vol-II
    • October 2023 – Vol-I
    • October 2023 – Vol-II
    • September 2023 – Vol-I
    • September 2023 – Vol-II
  • Lifestyle
  • Gallery
  • Mahabahu Books
    • Read Online
    • Free Downloads
  • E-Store
No Result
View All Result
Mahabahu.com
Home Tech

Are the New Digital Regulations Unlawful?

Kakali Das

by Kakali Das
March 14, 2023
in World, Media, Social Media, Tech
Reading Time: 7 mins read
0
জটিল চাকনৈয়াত সাম্প্ৰতিক বিশ্বঃ আমি ক’ত আছো!
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

Are the New Digital Regulations Unlawful?

Kakali Das

Kakali Das
KAKALI DAS

It’s indeed known to all that the government has decided to release new rules in order to regulate social media, digital media and the streaming platforms.

On closer examination of these rules it’s obvious that this is a turning point in the history of the internet in our country, because as the rules stand right now, if they are implemented it will change the way we communicate, consume content, and the way we are informed about what’s going on in the country, because of the way they are designed. How constitutional are these rules in the way that they are designed?                                                                                 

Are these rules constitutional because they seem to be stepping on the toes of privacy, of freedom of speech, even perhaps extending the IT Act beyond what it should be?

It is a turning moment not just in how the internet will be regulated in India, but in how artistic freedom, the press, our personal communication and essentially how the citizens will be regulated as Indians. In my opinion, the rules the Ministries brought out in the 25th of February are extremely significant.

RelatedPosts

How Ethical Design Can Propel Assam into the Future While Honoring Its Roots

How Ethical Design Can Propel Assam into the Future While Honoring Its Roots

June 15, 2025
How AI Can Empower Assam’s Flood-Prone Communities for a Resilient Future

How AI Can Empower Assam’s Flood-Prone Communities for a Resilient Future

June 14, 2025
Data breach and masking of data

তথ্য-শোষণ ! আমাৰ তথ্য–আমাৰ অধিকাৰ

June 13, 2025

As we know, it regulates the three significant categories of services – social media intermediaries, digital media and OTT platforms like Netflix, Hotstar, Amazon Prime, Zee5 etc.

No one denies that the internet or social media platforms do need to be regulated. In most constitutional democracies, the quest for regulation is a careful one, where there is a need to balance competing interests – the interest of speech and expression versus interests that we have in our society in protecting our children, in regulating hate speech and in keeping the citizens safe.

OTT1

We are not at issue or odds here on the needs to regulate; what we are at issue with is how the authorities regulate and how do they come up with rules that will regulate our entire fabric of thoughts and expression!

The primary question that arises – Is it a multi-lateral conversation? Did the government draw in opinions from both experts or entities that will regulate, as well as citizens?

In constitutional democracies, this expectation before us bring in new legal paradigm. The concerned authorities are attempting in regulating multifarious entities which each have different end products – the purpose of OTT platforms like Netflix, Amazon Prime is storytelling with artistic freedom and entertainment in mind, the purpose of digital media, for ex, Scroll, Quint, Wire is to hold governments to account, to break stories of importance that citizens need to know about.

These are two different functions with contrasting goals. These illustrations exhibit that the new rules seek to regulate two extremely different entities – the press and the entertainment with the same oversight mechanism. When we assess constitutionality, it’s not just about impugning motive. People aren’t usually interested in knowing which party is behind the passing of these laws and which is opposing it.

We ought to be interested in the legality or illegality, constitutionality or unconstitutionality of any law.

OTT platforms

These rules, too, vehemently pinpoints that these platforms should be willing to share and disclose the origin point of a message if asked for by a court, or any department of a government.

This authorisation breaks entirely the whole idea of end-to-end encryption. As a result of which, these companies will no longer be able to function under their existing encrypted rule.

But more importantly, the companies will actually have to trace a person sending a message and delete the content of the message within a specific timeframe. Doesn’t it violate the right to privacy given to us by the supreme court?

The government cannot assess the rules in isolation. The rules exist with two other features that impact both them and us. Firstly, there is no standalone data protection law in India.

There’s a bill that’s pending for years. Secondly, the 2009 variation of the IT Act already provides, in certain cases, decryption to be provided for. Now, in 2021 the government brought a third law which says that the first originators identity must be disclosed. The government already has access to the messages. How do we assess the need for legislation if the rules are disproportionate to the interests that they seek to serve?

We do so by seeking the one which already exists, and what is being infringed on by what exists at present. The government already has provision for decryption, the lack of data protection law, followed by the identity of who sends out what messages. The intermediaries will require disclosing that identity, which to my mind disproportionately burdens the rights to privacy, speech, expression and conscience.

netflix on an imac
Photo by cottonbro on Pexels.com

A lot in this document is papered with vague words like ‘mischievous’, ‘dangerous’, ‘unlawful’ which aren’t defined, and it’s too vague as to who makes these decisions, who decides what is mischievous or not!

For an instance, let’s assume I sent a message to a friend which he/she thought was funny, then that friend sent it on to somebody else who thought it was offensive, but not in the context that I sent it to the friend.

Who decides what mischief is and under what law is mischief illegal in this country?

If we look at the political substrata, the context in which these OTT platforms, social mediaries and digital media operates today, in case if any content offends a citizen, he/she gets to go to court, which these platforms are well aware of.

So, the government already has existing mechanism in place; it’s not as though one finds something offensive and there’s no remedy for it.

Netflix, Amazon Prime have learnt that the Indian Penal Code is extremely potent in slowing down their functioning if citizens find any content offensive. That mechanism already exists and digital media too is well-informed about it.

Then, what is it that these rules are trying to mend?

Why is it that both the OTT platforms and digital media will now require a grievance officer, an independent body, followed by an inter-departmental committee – an oversight mechanism established by the ministry, presumably consisting of bureaucrats?

[Images from different sources]

Mahabahu.com is an Online Magazine with collection of premium Assamese and English articles and posts with cultural base and modern thinking.  You can send your articles to editor@mahabahu.com / editor@mahabahoo.com ( For Assamese article, Unicode font is necessary)

Share this:

  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Like this:

Like Loading...
Tags: IT ActOTT platform
Kakali Das

Kakali Das

Related Posts

How Ethical Design Can Propel Assam into the Future While Honoring Its Roots
Tech

How Ethical Design Can Propel Assam into the Future While Honoring Its Roots

by Sanjeev Sarma
June 15, 2025
0

How Ethical Design Can Propel Assam into the Future While Honoring Its Roots SANJEEV SARMA SANJEEV SARMA Tech with a...

Read moreDetails
How AI Can Empower Assam’s Flood-Prone Communities for a Resilient Future

How AI Can Empower Assam’s Flood-Prone Communities for a Resilient Future

June 14, 2025
Data breach and masking of data

তথ্য-শোষণ ! আমাৰ তথ্য–আমাৰ অধিকাৰ

June 13, 2025
icebergs floating in the water near a body of water

Greenland Ice Sheet Melted 17 Times Faster During May Heatwave

June 13, 2025
Ngũgĩ’s Ideas on Language: Relevant Here and Now

Ngũgĩ’s Ideas on Language: Relevant Here and Now

June 11, 2025
Sea Levels Rise: Will the movie ‘Waterworld’ become a reality soon?

Vanishing Shores, Shifting Borders: The Global Warming Reshaping India, Bangladesh, and Assam

June 10, 2025
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
জ্যোতি সঙ্গীত – প্ৰথম খণ্ড

জ্যোতি প্ৰসাদ আগৰৱালাৰ কবিতা

August 7, 2021
অসমীয়া জনজাতীয় সংস্কৃতিঃ সমন্বয় আৰু সমাহৰণ

অসমীয়া জনজাতীয় সংস্কৃতিঃ সমন্বয় আৰু সমাহৰণ

November 19, 2024
আলাবৈ ৰণ: শৰাইঘাটৰ যুদ্ধৰ পটভূমিত

 লাচিত : শৰাইঘাটৰ যুদ্ধ আৰু ইয়াৰ ঐতিহাসিক তাৎপৰ্য

November 24, 2024
FREEDOM FIGHTERS OF ASSAM

FREEDOM FIGHTERS OF ASSAM

August 15, 2024
man in black shirt standing on top of mountain drinking coffee

মোৰ হিমালয় ভ্ৰমণৰ অভিজ্ঞতা

0
crop businessman giving contract to woman to sign

Loan Waivers : LOOKING BACK@ 2015

0
What is the Burqa and is it mandatory for all Muslim women to wear it?

What is the Burqa and is it mandatory for all Muslim women to wear it?

0
person in black tank top

বৃক্ক বিকলতা বা কিডনি ফেইলৰ

0
close up of disassembled electronic circuit boards

Environmental Impacts of Electronic Waste & Potential Pathways for its Management

June 15, 2025
How Ethical Design Can Propel Assam into the Future While Honoring Its Roots

How Ethical Design Can Propel Assam into the Future While Honoring Its Roots

June 15, 2025
পইতা পালমৰা নহয়, বৰং পুষ্টিকৰ খাদ্য

পইতা পালমৰা নহয়, বৰং পুষ্টিকৰ খাদ্য

June 15, 2025
How AI Can Empower Assam’s Flood-Prone Communities for a Resilient Future

How AI Can Empower Assam’s Flood-Prone Communities for a Resilient Future

June 14, 2025

Popular Stories

  • জ্যোতি সঙ্গীত – প্ৰথম খণ্ড

    জ্যোতি প্ৰসাদ আগৰৱালাৰ কবিতা

    11906 shares
    Share 4762 Tweet 2976
  • শ্ৰীমন্ত শংকৰদেৱৰ সাহিত্যৰাজি

    1377 shares
    Share 551 Tweet 344
  • পৰিৱেশ সুৰক্ষা আৰু আমাৰ দায়িত্ব 

    2859 shares
    Share 1144 Tweet 715
  • অসমীয়া জনজাতীয় সংস্কৃতিঃ সমন্বয় আৰু সমাহৰণ

    7218 shares
    Share 2887 Tweet 1805
  •  লাচিত : শৰাইঘাটৰ যুদ্ধ আৰু ইয়াৰ ঐতিহাসিক তাৎপৰ্য

    5507 shares
    Share 2203 Tweet 1377
  • ড্ৰাগছ : এক সামাজিক ব্যাধি

    3058 shares
    Share 1223 Tweet 765
  • দঁতাল হাতীৰ উঁয়ে খোৱা হাওদা

    867 shares
    Share 347 Tweet 217
  • ক্ষত্ৰিয় ৰাজবংশী আৰু ক্ষত্ৰিয় আন্দোলন

    177 shares
    Share 71 Tweet 44
  • Guwahati Is Sinking: 70 Years of Floods, No Lessons Learned!

    170 shares
    Share 68 Tweet 43
  • আঞ্চলিকতাবাদ- কি, কিয় আৰু কেনেকৈ?

    3150 shares
    Share 1260 Tweet 788
Mahabahu.com

Mahabahu: An International Journal Showcasing Premium Articles and Thought-Provoking Opinions on Global Challenges—From Climate Change and Gender Equality to Economic Upliftment.

Category

Site Links

  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact

We are Social

Instagram Facebook
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact

© 2021 Mahabhahu.com - All Rights Reserved. Published by Powershift | Maintained by Webx

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Oops!! The Content is Copy Protected.

Please ask permission from the Author.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News & Opinions
    • Politics
    • World
    • Business
    • National
    • Science
    • Tech
  • Mahabahu Magazine
    • December 2023 – Vol-I
    • December 2023 – Vol-II
    • November 2023 – Vol-I
    • November 2023 – Vol-II
    • October 2023 – Vol-I
    • October 2023 – Vol-II
    • September 2023 – Vol-I
    • September 2023 – Vol-II
  • Lifestyle
    • Fashion
    • Travel
    • Health
    • Food
  • Gallery
  • Mahabahu Books
    • Read Online
    • Free Downloads
  • E-Store
  • About Us

© 2021 Mahabhahu.com - All Rights Reserved. Published by Powershift | Maintained by Webx

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?
%d