France legalises Abortion Rights: Is it a social or political move?
KAKALI DAS
As humans, we are entitled to certain basic rights such as the right to life, education, work, freedom of speech, and freedom of religion. However, the right to abortion is often a contentious issue, despite being viewed by many as a fundamental right that all women should have.
France has taken a significant step by enshrining abortion as a constitutional right, becoming the first country in the world to do so.
In a landmark decision, 902 French lawmakers voted on the bill, with 780 in favor, 72 against, and 50 abstentions, demonstrating overwhelming support for the measure.
Supporters took to the streets in jubilation, with President Emmanuel Macron hailing the decision as a source of French Pride. The Eiffel Tower illuminated in celebration, adorned with a sparkling message: “my body, my choice.”
It’s indeed a proud moment for France, given the global context. Abortion rights are increasingly under threat worldwide, with 24 countries outright banning the procedure for women, and an additional 37 imposing heavy restrictions on access.
Since the overturn of abortion rights in the US in 2022, numerous states have implemented bans, forcing individuals to cross state borders to access the procedure. Meanwhile, Poland has significantly restricted abortion rights, outlawing it in many cases, and Hungary has also tightened its abortion laws.
Across Latin America, regressive anti-abortion laws prevail, while Africa grapples with the highest death rate from unsafe abortions. In countries like Laos and the Philippines, abortion remains illegal. Amidst this global backdrop, France stands out as a shining beacon for its progressive stance on abortion rights.
Was Paris’s decision to legalize abortion motivated by a genuine concern for women’s rights or was it primarily driven by political motives?
Let’s understand it!
France legalized abortion in 1975, initially permitting it up to 10 weeks of pregnancy. Over the years, this limit was extended to 12 weeks in 2001 and further to 14 weeks in 2022, ensuring broader access to the procedure.
Additionally, the country’s healthcare system has covered abortion since the 1980s. Furthermore, there is widespread support for abortion rights in France, with 86% of French citizens favoring them, including a significant portion of the right-wing population.
Prior to the vote, the French Prime Minister warned that the right to abortion was at risk, although data suggests otherwise, indicating that the right to abortion was not under threat.
Since 1975, France’s abortion law has undergone 9 revisions, with each update consistently expanding access to the procedure. Supported by both the public and lawmakers across the political spectrum, there has been widespread consensus on the importance of legal abortion in France. While enshrining abortion rights in the constitution is undoubtedly a significant step forward, the timing of this decision prompts the question: why now?
Among other factors, enshrining abortion rights in the constitution makes political sense for President Macron. Facing challenges in the National Assembly, with laws on immigration and pension reforms proving unpopular and divisive, this move seems to garner broader support.
While the left criticized him and the right deemed his efforts insufficient, the move to secure abortion rights appears to be a strategic move. With widespread lawmaker support, it serves to boost popularity for Macron but, technically, doesn’t significantly change the existing situation regarding abortion access on the ground.
In France, the right to abortion was already established in law, so on a practical level, this constitutional change doesn’t alter much besides enhancing Macron’s political standing. This move bolsters his credentials, positioning him as the French President who actively safeguarded abortion rights, highlighting the politics in the issue of abortion.
Abortion is frequently wielded as a political instrument worldwide. Republican-led states in the US have banned abortion to appease their voter base, while Joe Biden and the Democrats vigorously defend it, recognizing its significance to their supporters.
In Poland, abortion was outlawed during the right-wing government’s tenure, and now the new Prime Minister seeks to overturn it to align with his agenda.
Women’s bodies have become a political battleground worldwide, with lawmakers often overlooking their autonomy and rights regarding reproductive health decisions.
Shockingly, over 40% of women globally are deprived of the ability to make choices regarding their reproductive health, while over 200 million lack access to contraception. Tragically, over 1 million women are denied access to safe and legal abortion services.
France’s decision, when viewed against this global backdrop, appears largely symbolic. While undoubtedly significant and deeply personal for many women, it also carries political weight, much like any other abortion ruling worldwide.
Images from different sources
Mahabahu.com is an Online Magazine with collection of premium Assamese and English articles and posts with cultural base and modern thinking. You can send your articles to editor@mahabahu.com / editor@mahabahoo.com (For Assamese article, Unicode font is necessary)